Standing up for Good People

REACH OUT FOR HELP

Janesville, Wisconsin Personal Injury Attorney

Rock County's Premier Personal Injury Attorney

Serving the People of Southern Wisconsin. Our office is conveniently located in downtown Janesville in the historic Carriage Works Building. I encourage anyone in South Wisconsin to contact me about your personal injury case.

Paul Benson

Paul Benson

I’m a native of Janesville, and I’ve been standing up for victims of personal injury for years. When you reach out to me for a free case evaluation, I understand that you’re going through one of the most difficult times in your life. My main focus is ensuring that you’re treated fairly throughout your case—so that you can move forward.

GET TO KNOW ME

Injury Cases I Handle

There were nearly 130,000 car crashes in the state of Wisconsin in 2016 alone. When the insurance company tries to take advantage of you, retaliate with me by your side.

As of 2016, Wisconsin is home to roughly 4,000 assisted living facilities and 400 nursing homes. When you need to hold these for-profit organizations accountable, contact me.

When you have a perfectly legal claim against your insurance company and they refuse to cooperate, having an attorney on your side will increase your chances of success.

Premises liability and slip and fall cases are common, with wholesale and retail companies being involved in roughly 60% of all slip and fall claims.

Approximately 17% of all dog bites nationwide require medical treatment. When you’ve been injured due to a dog bite, I’ll educate you on your rights and next steps.

The number of Wisconsin professionals who cycle to work has steadily increased over the years. There are more bikes on the road—and more possibilities for accidents.

SEE ALL PRACTICE AREAS

Things you should

(and shouldn’t) do after a car accident

In the aftermath of an accident, every moment counts. Knowing what to do and not do after a car crash. Familiarize yourself with these crucial post-crash tips to strengthen your position against insurance companies focused on their own interests.

  • A red car and a black car are damaged in a car accident.

Reasons to Work With Me

Trial Experience

You deserve an experienced personal injury attorney. I’ve argued before the Court of Appeals, having litigated in state and US District courts. When you need confident representation in the courtroom, talk to me.

Focused on Personal Injury

I don’t “dabble” in personal injury law—I’m entirely devoted to it. From the insurance claims process to litigation in court, I deeply understand all the moving parts, and I know exactly how to proceed with your case.

Located in Janesville, Wisconsin

My office, located in downtown Janesville, makes it easy for people all around south central Wisconsin—including Green County, Rock County, Jefferson County, Walworth County, and more—to get legal support.

Insurance Law Knowledge

Insurance companies often exploit your limited understanding of insurance laws. With me by your side, they can't evade accountability. My commitment is to ensure you receive the compensation you deserve.

You have a lot on your plate at the moment. Let me assist you through this.

What My Clients Say

Read More
  • Paul Benson

Google Reviews

My services have consistently received 5-star ratings.

Experience The Difference With the Skilled Team at Paul Benson Law Firm


At Paul Benson Law Firm, you're not just getting legal representation—you're gaining allies in your fight for justice. My rockstar team has years of experience, especially when it comes to personal injury cases. From car accidents to wrongful death, medical malpractice claims to dog bites, we've seen it all and fought for justice every time. But don't just take my word for it; our 5-star ratings speak volumes about our commitment to our clients. No matter your situation, get in touch with us today for a free case evaluation, and together, we can work for your future.

ABOUT US
  • Team at Paul Benson Law Firm

Blog

By Paul Benson • November 11, 2026
How much time do you have to file a personal injury claim in Wisconsin? In Wisconsin, the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury claim is typically three years. This period is relatively longer compared to many other states, where the limit can be as short as one or two years. However, certain situations can alter this timeframe, but generally, you have three years to file your claim. What mistakes do people make assuming they have plenty of time to file a claim? Many people delay contacting a lawyer, thinking they have ample time. However, significant preparation is required before filing a claim, such as gathering evidence, ensuring medical bills are handled correctly, and managing medical treatment. Ideally, your case should be trial-ready when the suit is filed. If you approach a lawyer just before the deadline, it becomes challenging to prepare adequately, and some crucial evidence may no longer be retrievable. Does the clock always start running on the date of the accident? Typically, the statute of limitations begins on the accident date, but exceptions exist. The discovery rule applies if you didn't immediately discover your injury or the other party's negligence. This rule often applies in medical malpractice cases, where the injury might be discovered months after surgery. Additionally, for minors, the statute is tolled until they turn 18, allowing them to file a claim as adults. Military service or imprisonment can also toll the statute of limitations. What happens if someone misses the filing deadline? If you miss the statute of limitations, your case is likely lost. Wisconsin law provides little grace for missing deadlines. Although certain legal doctrines might offer slim chances to revive a case, they are low-probability options. It's essential to file a complaint at the courthouse within the three-year period to keep your claim alive, regardless of ongoing insurance negotiations. Can ongoing insurance negotiations affect the statute of limitations? Yes, ongoing negotiations can lead to missing the statute of limitations. Insurance companies are not obligated to inform you about filing deadlines, and they cannot provide legal advice. If the limitation period lapses during negotiations, the company can refuse to pay, leaving you without recourse. Can you share a case where timing was a major issue? Timing issues frequently arise, especially when clients approach right before the statute of limitations expires. For instance, a client with a brain injury from a car accident had unresolved medical issues that extended beyond three years. Despite ongoing treatment, the lawsuit had to be filed to preserve the claim, illustrating the challenges of dealing with cases where injury recovery is prolonged. What becomes harder to prove when too much time passes? As time passes, evidence issues become significant, especially for liability. Video footage might be overwritten, witnesses may relocate or become unreachable, and even memories can fade. These factors can severely weaken a case, especially when it relies on corroborating evidence beyond personal testimony. What surprises people most about the deadlines for injury claims in Wisconsin? Many are surprised to learn that claims against governmental entities have a much shorter deadline of 120 days, compared to the usual three years. This includes injuries involving city or county vehicles or incidents on government property. Missing this shorter window can result in losing the right to pursue a claim entirely. What is an example of a government entity with a 120-day claim deadline?  Claims involving city vehicles, county responsibilities like parks, or university employees fall under the 120-day deadline. For instance, if a University of Wisconsin employee causes an accident while on duty, you must act within 120 days to file a notice of claim, even if the employee wasn't in a university vehicle. Missing this deadline can exclude the university's insurance from being liable, highlighting the importance of knowing these specific timelines.
By Paul Benson • October 29, 2026
Can You File A Valid Injury Claim If You've Had A Similar Injury Or Medical Condition Before An Accident? Yes, you can file a valid injury claim even if you've had a similar injury or medical condition before the accident. These are known as pre-existing injuries in legal terms, and they play a significant role in the case. Wisconsin law allows you to claim for the worsening of that injury. The key is in how the pre-existing condition is framed within the context of the case. Why Do Insurance Companies Focus On A Person's Medical History After An Injury Claim Is Filed? Insurance companies scrutinize medical histories because it's one of their primary strategies to reduce the value of a claim. Their goal is to create doubt and confusion, potentially leading to a lower settlement. By highlighting past injuries or conditions, they aim to suggest that the current injury isn't solely due to the recent incident. How Can Regular Treatment For Maintenance Be Documented To Avoid Affecting An Injury Claim? Doctors should document pain levels, reasons for visits, and any changes over time. The quality of medical note-taking can vary, and if notes aren't helpful, additional documentation may be needed. This could involve obtaining a letter or deposition from the doctor to provide context. Are Insurance Companies Aiming To Pay As Much As Possible On Claims? No, insurance companies aim to pay as little as possible on claims. Their duty is to their shareholders or policyholders, and they use strategies like examining pre-existing conditions to minimize payouts. They look for any aspect in your medical history that could explain your injuries as unrelated to the current incident. How Can You Determine If An Accident Has Worsened An Existing Injury? Medical records are crucial in determining if an accident has worsened a pre-existing injury. Ideally, these records will document pain levels, range of motion, and daily activities both before and after the incident. Changes in these areas can indicate worsening due to the accident. What Kinds Of Medical Records Are Most Important In Injury Claims Involving Pre-existing Conditions? Important records often come from chiropractors, physical therapists, or specialists like orthopedic surgeons. These records detail subjective symptoms and objective measurements like pain levels and range of motion, which are critical in distinguishing between old and new injuries. Does A Pre-existing Condition Automatically Reduce The Value Of A Claim? Not necessarily. While a pre-existing condition can complicate a claim, it doesn't automatically reduce its value. The impact of the new incident on the pre-existing injury must be clearly demonstrated. Often, cases involving significant pre-existing conditions require litigation to ensure fair compensation. Should Someone Ever Refrain From Pursuing A Claim Due To A Previous Injury? Generally, no. There is always potential value in a claim due to the worsening of an injury, and sometimes it can be even more valuable. However, claims involving emotional or mental injuries may require careful consideration due to potential privacy concerns. Should You Release All Your Previous Medical Records To An Insurance Company After An Injury? No, you should not release all your medical records to an insurance company. They may use AI tools to sift through extensive records to find anything that could undermine your claim. The release of prior records is usually negotiated, often limited to a few years prior to the incident. Can You Share A Real-life Example Where A Pre-existing Injury Was A Major Issue In A Claim? A retired man injured while crossing a crosswalk had previously undergone knee surgery. The insurance company tried to attribute his symptoms to past issues. However, by demonstrating that the surgery was meant to improve his quality of life and that the accident caused a setback, a favorable settlement was achieved. What Challenges Arise When Insurance Companies Blame Symptoms On An Older Injury? Insurance companies can hire experts to testify that symptoms are due to an older injury, not the recent incident. Overcoming this requires a skilled attorney who can effectively cross-examine these expert witnesses and demonstrate their potential biases. What Does Wisconsin Law Say About Aggravating Or Worsening A Pre-existing Condition? Wisconsin law includes the "egg shell skull rule," meaning defendants are responsible for injuries as they find the plaintiff, even if they are more susceptible to injury. Defendants are also responsible for the worsening of a pre-existing condition, though not for the pre-existing condition itself.
By Paul Benson • October 14, 2026
Can A Passenger In A Vehicle Accident Pursue An Injury Claim In Wisconsin? Yes, passengers can pursue an injury claim in Wisconsin. The process may become complicated when determining which insurance policy applies first, as different policies have various procedures for payment order. Initially, the responsible driver's insurance policy is the first to cover the passenger's claims. Who Can A Passenger Make A Claim Against After An Accident? A passenger can make a claim against the responsible driver's insurance. If that doesn't fully cover the damages, they can pursue claims under uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. This typically involves the policy of the car they were in and then their own policy, as personal coverage follows the individual rather than staying with the vehicle. What If Multiple Drivers Contribute To The Accident? In multi-car accidents, fault is apportioned among the drivers. A jury might assign fault by percentages, but often this is resolved through negotiations between insurance companies and lawyers, who aim to agree on a fair distribution of liability. The focus is generally on identifying the driver with the most insurance coverage to maximize recovery. How Do Injury Claims Work When Passengers Are Riding With Family Or Friends? In Wisconsin, the Direct Action Statute allows passengers to sue the insurance company directly without naming the individual driver, such as a family member or friend. This relieves personal conflict and enables the injured party to make a claim against the insurance policy rather than the individual. What Types Of Compensation Can An Injured Passenger Recover? Injured passengers can recover compensation for three primary areas: medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Medical expenses cover all treatment-related costs, lost wages account for any income lost due to the accident, and pain and suffering encompass intangible damages. What Challenges Do Passengers Face With Insurance Companies After An Accident? Passengers often encounter challenges such as policy limits when multiple people are injured, and issues with not wearing seat belts, which insurers may argue exacerbated injuries. These factors can complicate the claim process and affect the compensation amount. Can Passengers Have More Claim Options Than They Realize? Yes, passengers may have more options than they initially think, especially if the driver's insurance policy can be claimed against. Even if the passenger is unfamiliar with the driver, such as a classmate, they can still file a claim if that driver is at fault. What Challenges Arise In Accidents Involving Multiple Injured Passengers? The main challenge is often inadequate policy limits to cover all injuries, requiring negotiations to distribute available funds fairly among those injured. The "made whole" doctrine may help negotiate better terms with health insurers for medical expense coverage, but this can be complicated by various legal and federal stipulations. Are There Options To Pursue Additional Compensation If Insurance Is Insufficient? In practice, pursuing additional compensation from the at-fault individual personally is challenging, as insurance companies require a release of their insured driver in settlements. If coverage is significantly inadequate, one might need to go to trial, but this is often a complex and difficult route. What Surprises People About Passenger Injury Claims? People are often surprised to learn their own insurance policy follows them, and that insurers may not pay the full limit due to offset rules. Additionally, insurance companies can be aggressive in minimizing payouts, which underscores the necessity of having legal representation to ensure fair treatment. Why Might An Injured Passenger Need An Attorney, Even For Minor Claims? Insurance companies are more aggressive in settling claims quickly for less money than in the past, often offering low initial settlements. An attorney can help protect the passenger's rights and negotiate a fair settlement, as insurance adjusters aim to settle claims for as little as possible.
Read More

No matter how tough or complex your case, I won't give up.


I’m passionate about your case going well because I understand how difficult this time can be. You’re juggling all the issues that come with a personal injury: handling time missed from work, repairing or replacing your vehicle, recovering from your injuries, and arguing with the responsible party and your insurance company. You weren’t the one who caused the incident, so why should you suffer? I fight hard to make the suffering end so you can get back to what you enjoy.

Let's start with a free case evaluation

Hiring a personal injury attorney can be a difficult decision as you weigh the financial aspect of your case. To make this easier for you, I offer a free case evaluation to every single one of my clients. If you think you have a case, or if you know you need someone to represent you, contact me. We’ll meet in my downtown Janesville office and I’ll explain your rights and options — and I won’t charge you a penny for it.

We'll strategize with your needs in mind

If you decide to work with me on your case, our next step will be to develop a sound legal plan. I’ll customize this plan according to the unique elements of your situation, and I’ll prepare for every possible outcome — including a trial — so that there are no surprises. We’ll be ready to handle any route the insurance companies try to take.

I'll be with you every step of the way

From there, you can rest assured that I’ll be the one to work with you on your case from beginning to end. I’ll never hand you off to a paralegal or assistant, and I’ll be accessible anytime you need me. As your case progresses and I deal with the insurance companies, I’ll provide updates and explain what everything means. If you’re considering working with me, I encourage you to fill out the form below. You’ll see right away that I’ll personally reach out to you within 24 hours — and you can expect that level of service through every step of your personal injury case.